“Bagels” Unlimited – Fairmount vs. St. Viateur

Hi y’all. I hope everyone’s February is going well. The last few weeks have been especially hectic for me, which is why, instead of boring everyone with repeats of mac and cheese and pie or chili, I’ve taken a step back from blogging. I usually write about things I cook, as opposed to restaurants or take-out. The lack of take-out entries is probably due to the lack of take-out restaurants that I’ve found in Montreal. My neighborhood is practically devoid of all take-out. I’ve been craving bagels lately, and today I made the schlepp up the mountain to try out the two famous Montreal places: Fairmount Bagel and St. Viateur Bagel. (Fairmount Bagel located at 74 Avenue Fairmount Ouest; St. Viateur @ 263 Rue Saint Viateur Ouest)

From both bagelries, I ordered a poppyseed bagel, a poppyseed matzoh, and a freebie – something found at one place but not the other. The freebie I picked up @ St. Viateur was a rosemary and sea salt bagel. At Fairmount it was the bozo bagel… two strands of twisted bagel dough, covered with one side in poppyseeds and sesame seeds on the other.

The matzoh for me was a first – I love matzoh, but I didn’t know matzoh could be made and not just bought in a box. This matzoh is not the kind I would make peanut butter and jelly sandwiches with, but it was good. The matzoh from both stores could not be covered more in poppyseeds than it was – the top sides were thoroughly coated. The matzoh from Fairmount was squarer, and had visually more even lines – St. Viateur’s matzoh seemed more stretched in the general shape of matzoh but not precisely formed, but overall, I liked the matzoh from St. Viateur’s more. The dough had an almost nutty flavor, and was slightly softer.

In terms of bagels, I thought the bagels from both places were pretty interchangeable. Neither one stands out in my mind as phenomenal. The bagels from Fairmount seemed to me unnecessarily sweet, and the bagels from St. Viateur tasted especially boiled instead of baked. The part of the St. Viateur bagel that didn’t have a lot of poppyseeds on it didn’t have a lot of flavor itself, but went well with creamcheese. I did love the Rosemary Sea Salt bagel, but I don’t know that I can call any of these bagels, “bagels,” in my truest sense of the word. The Fairmount Bozo bagel was comparatively large compared to all of the other bagels, but was honestly the same size as a normal Jersey bagel would be. I’m also not the biggest fan of sesame in the world.

In general, I would eat a Rosemary Sea Salt bagel from St. Viateur Bagel again. I don’t know that I would go out of my way for any of the other bagels, and while the matzoh is a novelty for me, it’s not something I have to have. Furthermore, the staff seemed a little more friendly at St. Viateur than they did at Fairmount. Bottomline: try a Rosemary Sea Salt bagel @ St. Viateur, but don’t walk 45 minutes through rain and snow one way to get one. Wait for a day when the walk will be nice. Their bagels come closer to a New York/New Jersey replica than Fairmount do in my mind, but the next time I’m home I’ll have to load up with bagels to put in my freezer in Montreal. The Montreal bagels are okay, but they’re not the same if you’re used to Jersey’s finest.

Pictures are matzoh (Fairmount on L; St. V on R); rosemary sea salt from St. V; stack (top to bottom) of Fairmount poppy, Fairmount bozo bagel, St. V poppy; all sides of the bozo bagel.  Enjoy!








One thought on ““Bagels” Unlimited – Fairmount vs. St. Viateur

  1. Pingback: Poppyseed Matzoh | sophisticatedjerseygirl

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s